Mommy Wars: The Fight No Woman Wins
April 16th, 2009Diversity in opinion is a good thing. It is interesting to hear other people’s views on what works best for them as mothers. The problem is, it is a sensitive topic. How a woman raises her children is a seriously personal tie to her worthiness as a person in a lot of ways. Nobody proudly says, “I hope to have my kids grow up to be lazy, uneducated, and live on kool aid and cookies.” We all want our children to have healthy habits, learn as much as possible, and go far in everything they do.
Recently a general interest parenting section on a secular message board I frequent had a total meltdown. Cyber arrows flew as a debate got ugly about breast feeding vs. formula feeding. Articles were posted supporting both sides, formula was likened to poison, extended breast feeding was referred to as “weird” and “creepy.” Feelings were hurt, anger ran high, some women eventually were banned for their outbursts. Then 2 weeks or so later, another bru-ha-ha broke out over whether it is kind to let a child cry himself to sleep. More drama, more articles with dire predictions, and more banning.
And it isn’t just secular sites. In a less angry way, I’ve seen it on Christian boards related to other things like home school vs. public, courting vs. dating, quiverfull vs. birth control. Mothers can really attack each other over these issues because every mother worries that they are making the right decisions for their children. So by defending a position passionatly, a mother can feel like she is not only discussing her view on sleep training, but going to the very core of who she is as a parent and how much she loves her child.
This particular website, Christian Homekeepers, used to have another name “Titus 2 Christian Homekeepers” on the old message board format. The Bible verses this moniker referred to are Titus 2:3-5.
“3Older women likewise are to be reverent in their behavior, not malicious gossips nor enslaved to much wine, teaching what is good, 4so that they may encourage the young women to love their husbands, to love their children, 5to be sensible, pure, workers at home, kind, being subject to their own husbands, so that the word of God will not be dishonored.”
The moderators and administrators here at Christian Homekeepers do a beautiful job of keeping these principles in mind on the message board. People don’t agree 100% of the time but every one has learned how to take a breath, count to ten, and comment on issues with love and encouragement. The phrase “older women” doesn’t even have to apply to chronological age, either. It can be a mother with kids older than mine. She might be 10 years younger than me, but she knows more about some aspects of child rearing because she’s been there already, and I have often learned from women my junior on this site.
I love learning from other mothers, talking about our kids, sharing struggles and triumphs. I think we all do, that’s why there are hundreds of boards and websites all over the Internet where women share their mother experiences. It can be one of the greatest resources to have advice and testimonials from other moms as I navigate the challenges of upcoming tasks like potty training or weaning or choosing a pre-school. But it can also be one of the most hurtful experiences to go online and read that you just poisoned, abused, or otherwise stunted your child because someone doesn’t know how to share their views compassionately.
I am no better than other women when it comes to being decisive and determined about the choices I’ve made for my kids, but I hope that with God’s help I’ll remember to always take a breath and remember we’re all in this mothering job together before shooting off my mouth. I can “be good” very easily on a site like this one where I know there is a high standard, but I see no reason not to keep that Titus 2 Standard wherever I go in cyberspace or the real world.
![]()









