Cream Of Soup Recipes

You know that casserole or recipe that calls for a can of cream of something soup?  And you look and you have none?  Or you’re like me and you just prefer not to use them?  Here are three recipes to replace those cream of soups in your cooking.  I have both a from-scratch soup and an instant version for you. 

The basic plan?  For the from-scratch soup you make a heavy white sauce using butter, flour and milk or broth and add flavors like chicken, mushrooms or asparagus. Each recipe makes about 10 ounces so its like having a can of undiluted cream of soup at your fingertips.

Basic Cream Of Soup
1. In a small, heavy saucepan, melt 4 tablespoons of butter over low heat.
2. Blend 4 tablespoons of flour into the melted butter.
Add 1/4 teaspoon of salt.
3. Cook over low heat, stirring, for 4 to 5 minutes. Don’t skimp on the cooking time. If you do, your soup may taste of raw flour.
4. Slowly add 1 cup of milk, stirring constantly.
5. Continue cooking slowly until smooth and thickened.

For Cream Of Chicken Soup
Replace half the milk with good chicken stock OR add 1 tablespoon chicken bouillon granules to the milk.
Add 1/2 cup small bits of cooked chicken after step 5

For Cream Of Asparagus Soup
Add 1/2 cup drained, minced, canned asparagus and a pinch of garlic powder after step 5

For Cream Of Mushroom Soup
In a large skillet over medium heat cook 1 cup diced mushrooms in 1 tablespoon butter. Don’t crowd the skillet and cook til the mushrooms are light brown in color.
Add the cooked mushrooms after step 5.

For those times when you need an instant solution, here is my Instant Cream Of Whatever Soup Mix.  This is the basic recipe.  In the instructions for making the soup out of the mix, I’ll show you what you need for making each type of soup, Cream of Celery, Cream of Mushroom and Cream of Chicken.

Instant Cream Of Whatever Soup Mix
2 cups dry milk powder
¾ cup cornstarch or cook-type clear jel
1 teaspoon onion powder
½ teaspoon dried thyme
½ teaspoon dried basil
½ teaspoon dried parsley
¼ teaspoon black pepper

Combine 1/3 cup dry mix with 1 ¼ cups water in a small saucepan. Whisk until smooth.
On medium heat, bring to a boil. Cook and stir for 2 minutes, until thick. Cool.

For Cream Of Chicken Soup
Replace half the milk with some good chicken stock. I have also used a teaspoon of chicken bouillon granules in place of the stock and it turned out very well.
After you add the milk, stir in 1/2 cup small pieces of cooked chicken.

For Cream Of Asparagus Soup
After adding the milk to the instant soup, add 1/2 cup of drained, minced, canned asparagus and a pinch or so of garlic powder.

For Cream Of Mushroom Soup
In a large skillet over medium heat cook 1 cup finely diced mushrooms in 1 tablespoon butter and a drizzle of olive oil. Don’t crowd the skillet with mushrooms or they will get watery. Let them brown til they are golden in color. Add the cooked mushrooms after adding the milk in the basic recipe. Another thing I have done is to add shitake mushroom powder to the soup after adding the milk. Its strong flavored and makes the soup taste I add just 1 Tablespoon. I make the mushroom powder by dehydrating the mushrooms then blending up the dried mushrooms. Store mushroom powder in a glass jar, tightly covered, or in the freezer. 

You will probably use these immediately when you make them, but if you need to store them, keep them covered tightly in the refrigerator for about 3 days. They won’t keep much longer than that because of the milk and butter in them.

About Sylvia

Sylvia Britton is the owner of the Christian HomeKeeper website and ministry and began the ministry in 1997 when her husband brought home their first PC. She and her husband Mark live in Tennessee and are the parents of 5 grown children and grandparents to five so far. They homeschooled their five children from 1991 to 2016. Sylvia is a Christian and worship leader in her local Church. You can follow her on Facebook or consider joining her Facebook Group called Christian Homekeepers and Like her official CHK Page on Facebook.
This entry was posted in Cooking. Bookmark the permalink.

29 Responses to Cream Of Soup Recipes

  1. Val says:

    Thanks for sharing these!!!

  2. Pingback: Everything Is Better With Gravy

  3. Rose Curran says:

    Sylvia, Thank you so much for these recipes. I use mushroom and chicken through out the year making chicken or turkey pot pies and I have always wanted to make my own and stop buying the processed stuff. So again THANK YOU!

  4. Ella Gunter says:

    Hi Sylvia! Can I copy this and print it for my own use at home?

    God bless,


    • Sylvia says:

      Yes of course you can, Ella!

      Anything here on the site can be printed out for anyone’s personal use.

      If you’d like to make copies, please email me
      Christianhomekeeper (at) yahoo (dot) com

  5. Pingback: How Country Folks Eat

  6. Pingback: Weekly Recipe Wrap Up – The 1/1/11 Edition | Delicious Obsessions

  7. Trasee says:

    I’ve never heard of using beans as a substitute for butter and oil in baking. I would love to know more about this. Have you tried it yet?

  8. Connie says:

    I am preparing for severe hard times when we may not even have electricity and so am dehydrating most everything from my garden (rather than freezing it). I can but not too much because I don’t want to destroy all the food value.

    Anyway, I am on the lookout for ways to make cream-of-xxx soup bases that do not rely on butter or milk, so that I can have it available long-term. The other day I learned about substituting bean puree for oil and cooked beans for butter in baking, so I’m wondering if I can just dehydrate cooked bean-based and bean puree-based mixtures for cream-of-xxx soup bases. I know I can purchase freeze-dried butter and freeze-dried milk, and freeze-dried soup and meal mixes, etc., but they’re expensive and usually contain MSG so I’m not interested in that. I know I can dehydrate beans and bean puree separately, but I’m looking for information as to how to pull all this together.

    If you have recipes of this nature, I’d really appreciate your posting them! Many thanks!

  9. June says:

    I make large batches of “Cream of…” soups and freeze them without any problems. I have never used a canning jar though. I would maybe place a protective layer over the top of the soup to keep it from getting freezer burn. I know a lot of people don’t like to use plastic wrap or aluminum foil, but I think if the soup is cold when you place it on top it would be okay?

  10. Sylvia says:

    Pressure canning would probably not be an option because of the milk involved. I’m not sure what freezing would do to the texture, either. I make what I know I will need at the beginning of the week and it keeps well, covered, in the refrigerator all week.

  11. Kirsten says:

    What about freezing these in wide-mouth pint jars? How would that work out? I never seem to have room in my fridge for the large amounts I’d like to make of things like this. Or, anybody know of if I could pressure-can something like this?

  12. Pingback: Q & A: Healthy Condensed Cream Soups? | GNOWFGLINS

  13. Tammy says:

    Thanks! I’ll give it a try!

  14. Traci says:

    Tammy, when I make chicken stock, I add lots of onion, garlic, a stalk or two of celery and sometimes carrots. Cover and simmer until chicken is done. Add some salt and pepper and you have a delicious chicken stock.

  15. Tammy says:

    Do you know how to make a flavorful stock base (chicken or beef), without all the msg? Even bouillon has msg, and I’m trying to avoid using it. I’ve tried making stock from simmering a chicken overnight (had a recipe I followed), but it was flavorless, so I must’ve done something wrong…

    • Sylvia says:

      Tammy I make chicken stock a little like Traci makes it.

      Only sometimes do I use the whole chicken to make stock. Most of the time I use a chicken carcass where I have roasted the bird and then removed the meat.

      So you can use these instructions with a whole bird or just the carcass.

      I use a small whole onion studded with two whole cloves, a large carrot, a large stalk of celery, 5 black peppercorns and a bundle of thyme, rosemary and parsley. I tie the fresh herbs together with kitchen string to make the bundle. And I use about 1 Tablespoons of vinegar. The vinegar helps get the protein out of the bones and into your stock.

      You can use other seasonings like tumeric or ginger instead and in addition to the herbs.

      I place everything into a pot of water with the carcass and bring it to a boil. Then I lower the heat and allow it to simmer for about 2 hours.

      Once it has simmered for a couple of hours, I allow it to cool, then I refrigerate stock, carcass and all. If you use a whole bird, you can take the meat off the bones once its cooled, store the meat and refrigerate the stock and bones.

      A thick gelatinous layer will form on top of the stock after its been refrigerated. That layer is flavorful protein. Take the stock out of the frig once its cold.

      Gently heat the stock and other ingredients. Remove the bones and vegetables, strain if desired. There’s your stock! Now you can use it with your recipes and season it to taste with salt and pepper.

  16. Melissa says:

    Thanks for sharing this. I have been putting off making my own “cream of soup,” but I found a pretty, non-scratching whisk at the store the other day. So, now I can’t wait to use it!

  17. Marly says:

    Thank you so much for this recipe, Sylvia. I am excited to add this to my “homemade” file.

  18. Marg says:

    Ah! Now I know what to do with that can of asparagas. Cream of cabbage soup is good too, or broccoli, cauliflower, especially if you have a garden or a farmers market. Mmmm. I love cream soups!

  19. Molly says:

    This is wonderful!
    I used it this evening in my King Ranch Chicken!
    Thank you!

  20. Amy Johnson says:

    This is wonderful…thanks!

  21. Deb says:

    Thank you, Sylvia! I was wondering about this not long ago, since the canned creamed soups have MSGs.

  22. Cathy says:

    Mmmm! Sounds delicious and much better than the canned stuff!

  23. Kay says:

    Do you have a recommendation on how to adapt this recipe to make Cream of Celery soup? Thanks for posting these recipes. I have a similar recipe but am going to try yours.

    • Sylvia says:

      Yes I do. Celery must be cooked first so it will be tender. So dice 1 cup of celery (or use less if you prefer) and saute it in a little water or butter til tender. Add it after step 5.
      You may also add a pinch of celery seed to pep up the flavor.

  24. Leigh says:

    Thank you so much for posting these! This is fabulous…